best cookout tray order reddit

Best Cookout Tray Order: Reddit's Top Picks

By Emily WalkerFebruary 4, 2026

Gather 'round, food enthusiasts! We're diving into the heart of summer with a tantalizing topic that's sure to get your taste buds tingling - the ultimate cookout tray order, as inspired by the vibrant discussions on Reddit. So, let's fire up the grill, grab our aprons, and explore the best dishes to make your next backyard bash a mouthwatering success.

Reddit, the vast online forum, is a treasure trove of culinary wisdom, with users sharing their favorite recipes, cooking tips, and, of course, their dream cookout tray orders. We've scoured the threads to bring you the most drool-worthy, crowd-pleasing dishes that are sure to make your cookout the talk of the town. So, let's get grilling!

Meat Lovers' Delight

No cookout is complete without a fantastic selection of meats. Reddit users rave about these protein-packed stars that are guaranteed to satisfy even the hungriest of guests.

an image of the ultimate bbq cookout plate with instructions to make it easy and delicious

First up, we have the classic burger, a Reddit favorite that's as versatile as it is delicious. From juicy beef patties to mouthwatering turkey or veggie alternatives, burgers are a cookout staple that can be customized to everyone's liking. Don't forget the toppings - think crispy bacon, melted cheese, caramelized onions, and a secret sauce that'll have them begging for the recipe.

Brisket: The King of Slow Cooking

For those who appreciate the art of slow cooking, brisket is the king of the cookout. This tender, smoky beef masterpiece requires patience and skill, but the reward is a melt-in-your-mouth experience that'll leave your guests speechless. Reddit users swear by the Texas-style rubs and low-and-slow cooking methods that bring out the best in this humble cut of meat.

hot dogs, hamburgers and other food items are on display in tin foil trays

the ultimate bbq cookout platter is shown in this graphic above it's instructions

Cookout Tray Menu with Prices and Calories

Second only to brisket in the slow-cooked stakes is the pulled pork. Tender, juicy, and packed with flavor, pulled pork is a cookout game-changer. Reddit users recommend using a pork shoulder, a generous helping of your favorite BBQ sauce, and a slow cooker or smoker to achieve that perfect, fall-apart texture.

Chicken: The Versatile Cookout Star

Chicken is a cookout staple that can be prepared in countless ways, making it a crowd-pleaser for all ages. Reddit users suggest trying your hand at grilled chicken skewers, marinated in a zesty blend of olive oil, lemon, and herbs. Alternatively, go for a whole grilled chicken, rubbed with a flavorful spice blend and cooked low and slow for maximum juiciness.

For a fun twist on the classic chicken dish, consider chicken and waffles. This Southern-inspired delight is a surefire hit, with crispy fried chicken paired with fluffy waffles and a drizzle of spicy honey. Reddit users rave about this indulgent dish, perfect for a cookout with a side of Southern charm.

a hot dog and some foil wrapped food in a container on a wooden table top

several trays of food sitting on top of a blue and white checkered table cloth

Easy Cookout Food Ideas For A Crowd That Everyone Will Love

several trays of food sitting on top of a table covered in white clothed cloth

Sides That Steal the Show

While the meats may be the stars of the show, no cookout is complete without a fantastic selection of sides. Reddit users share their favorite accompaniments that'll have your guests going back for seconds (and thirds!).

No cookout spread is complete without a classic potato salad. Reddit users swear by the creamy, tangy combination of potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, celery, and a secret ingredient or two. For a healthier alternative, try a grilled potato salad, with crispy-skinned spuds tossed in a light vinaigrette.

Coleslaw: The Perfect Crunchy Companion

Coleslaw is the ultimate cookout sidekick, providing a refreshing crunch that cuts through the richness of the main event. Reddit users recommend trying a vinegar-based coleslaw, with a tangy dressing that'll wake up your taste buds. For a sweeter take, go for a creamy coleslaw, made with mayo, sour cream, and a touch of sugar.

several trays filled with meat sitting on top of a counter next to a stove

a table with different types of barbecues and hotdogs on it, as well as the words epic bbq checklist

a woman in a kitchen holding a plate of food with the words, my controversial buffet broke the internet just did a party

Creative BBQ Party Inspiration for a Fun and Flavorful Gathering

several trays of chicken wings, macaroni and cheese with other foods in them

a person holding a plate full of hot dogs and corn on the cob with other foods

a red tray filled with different types of food

several trays of food sit on the hood of a car parked in front of a parking lot

a plastic container filled with lots of different types of food on top of a counter

several trays of food are lined up on a counter top with candy bars in the background

Feed a Crowd For Cheap With These Food Ideas For Parties

No cookout spread would be complete without a mouthwatering BBQ sauce. Reddit users share their favorite homemade recipes, from sweet and tangy to spicy and smoky. Slather it on your meats, use it as a dipping sauce, or even drizzle it over your sides - this versatile condiment is a must-have at any cookout.

Corn on the Cob: A Cookout Classic

There's nothing quite like the sweet, smoky flavor of grilled corn on the cob. Reddit users suggest brushing your ears with a mixture of melted butter, garlic, and herbs, then wrapping them in foil and grilling until tender. For a fun twist, try Mexican street corn, with a creamy lime and chili seasoning that'll have your guests begging for more.

For a show-stopping side that'll have everyone reaching for seconds, consider grilled vegetable skewers. Reddit users recommend threading an assortment of colorful veggies onto skewers, then grilling until tender and slightly charred. Drizzle with a zesty balsamic glaze and serve - these veggie delights are sure to be a hit with both kids and adults alike.

Desserts and Drinks: The Sweet Finish

A fantastic cookout deserves an equally impressive finish. Reddit users share their favorite desserts and drinks that'll leave your guests with a sweet memory to savor.

No cookout is complete without a fruity, refreshing drink to wash down all that delicious food. Reddit users rave about homemade lemonade, made with freshly squeezed lemons, sugar, and a touch of mint. For a boozy twist, try a classic margarita, with a salted rim and a squeeze of fresh lime.

S'mores: The Campfire Classic

If you're lucky enough to have a fire pit or a cozy outdoor fireplace, then s'mores are a must-make dessert. Reddit users share their favorite variations, from classic chocolate and marshmallow to creative combos like peanut butter cups, cookies, and even fruity fillings. There's nothing quite like the gooey, melty perfection of a perfectly made s'more.

For a show-stopping dessert that'll have your guests oohing and aahing, try a grilled fruit crisp. Reddit users recommend slicing your favorite fruits, arranging them in a cast-iron skillet, and topping them with a crispy oat and nut streusel. Grill until golden and bubbly, then serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream - it's the perfect sweet finish to a fantastic cookout.

As the sun sets and the embers glow, there's nothing quite like the warmth of a cookout with loved ones. So, fire up the grill, gather your ingredients, and get ready to create a mouthwatering spread that'll have your guests raving. With these Reddit-inspired dishes, you're sure to host a cookout that'll be remembered for years to come. Happy grilling!